The 4350water Blog highlights some of the issues relating to proposals for potable reuse in Toowoomba and South East Qld. 4350water blog looks at related political issues as well.

Thursday, May 25, 2006

Councillor gags over bottled recycled water promotion ...

From ABC News (annotated):

25 May 2006

Councillor gags over bottled recycled water promotion

A critic of the Toowoomba water futures project in south-east Queensland says a plan to give away bottles of recycled sewage water to residents in the lead-up to the poll is a poor stunt.

Councillor Lyle Shelton says bottles of recycled effluent water from Singapore are being shipped in in a bid to secure votes at the July 29 poll.

He says residents should not be fooled by the promotion.

"Singapore is drinking one per cent recycled sewage water," he said.

"No amount of promotional bottles is going to change that fact and until other cities in the world adopt this at a rate that Toowoomba's looking at, we should take a cautious response like the Singapore people are taking a cautious response in a country that is not even a democracy."

Toowoomba Mayor Di Thorley says the bottles are not a promotional stunt.

She says they are being shipped in [at ratepayers' expense] to prove a point.

"Nobody is going to be able to quantify if people will change their mind. It is about them understanding that this water does not have an odour, is clear and is pure, remembering that this is 100 per cent recycled water," she said.

Source - ABC News - Councillor gags over bottled recycled water promotion.

Wasn't Mayor Thorley making no further comments during the referendum?

Wasn't she going to leave it to the "Kev and Al" show?

Seems she's unable to keep even that commitment.

Also seems the Mayor thinks that she will have to change people's minds. What happened to the 70% who supported her? That's enough to get the yes vote across the line. Is Council's polling telling them something different?

And she used the "pure" word - that's going to get you into trouble during the referendum period, Mayor Thorley.

It's interesting to watch the recycled sewage sippers - no-one really gulping it down. Not a lot of trust there. It is a stunt and it won't win people's trust. You simply can't undo the harm done over the past 10 months with a few sips of recycled Singapore sewage ...

6 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wonder how much each NEWater bottle is costing the Toowoomba ratepayers when you calculate shipping and customs inspecton fees. Bet it's not cheap. More ratepayers' money wasted on a Thorley stunt.

11:35 AM, May 25, 2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

If recycled water is such a great thing, why doesn't Singapore have any plans to go to 25-29% like the mayor's plan. Why stay at 1%? They're not a real democracy - they wouldn't need to ask the people. Why did they then build a desalination plant?

12:07 PM, May 25, 2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Because Singapore Health found problems!

1:31 PM, May 25, 2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bottled water has strict guidelines on what water is used in it.. No health department or consumer affairs would allow recycled sewage to be sold in shops, let alone imported and given freely to the public.

This is not a stunt Lyle Shelton, this is a criminal act, as she is telling lies to people and misleading the public again with the water testing, this isn't a competition, it's a referendum, and this is not informing the public of the truth.

She needs stoping now, before our city is committed to more then just 25% effluent, Beattie has plans for 100%, why else have we been left out of his new water scheme... because we will end up with effluent from Brisbane as well and Lord know where else.

Stop the buck now Vote NO!

1:17 AM, May 26, 2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Vote No and keep the information flowing.

2:01 AM, May 26, 2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

As the very brand shows, NEWater was launched in Singapore with quite a bit of hype, the attempted spin being that this was yet another technological first, a win for independent Singapore and a slap in the face of the nefarious Dr M. However, while Singapore's long-suffering citizens didn't object loudly to drinking their own piss, swallowing the government's BS was a bit too much to expect and Newater instantly became the butt of a million jokes. Within a week or two, the government realized that maybe this wasn't going to work quite as well as planned, and the media stopped mentioning the issue.

2:41 AM, May 26, 2006

 

Post a Comment

<< Home